0 items in cart

FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY Fast! Free! All items, all day, every day!

Page Content Begins Here
Sort Results
FILTERS (5) 389 FOUND Reset Done
Coming Soon
Glove Coach TRY OUR GLOVE COACH Answer a few simple questions to find your perfect glove.

Extra Stiff Stiff Catcher First Base Second Base

389 FOUND

Extra Stiff Stiff Catcher First Base Second Base CLEAR ALL
Popular Popular, click to sort ascending Latest Latest, click to sort descending Avg. Rating Avg. Rating, click to sort descending Savings Savings, click to sort descending $: Low to High $: Low to High, click to sort ascending $: High to Low $: High to Low, click to sort descending
Angled view of two brown and tan baseball gloves, one showing the pocket with A2000 and the other the back with a red W logo.
Wilson A2000 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100390115 $279.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of a white baseball glove with gray lacing, A2000 and Wilson logos on the palm.
Wilson A2000 Ice DP15 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100795115 $349.95 Price was: $379.95 Only At
Angled view of a black and tan catchers mitt showing a Heart of the Hide logo and Y Molina Pattern.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Yadier Molina 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: PROYM4CB $329.99 Price was: $349.99 Only at
Angled front view of a tan baseball glove with A2000 and Wilson branding, black lacing, and a yellow W logo.
Wilson A2000 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100969115 $299.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $224.95
Angled front view of a red and gray Wilson baseball glove with a red palm, TA logo, and Super SnakeSkin.
Wilson A2000 Super SnakeSkin Tim Anderson 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW101634115 $189.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of two brown and black softball gloves with A2000, Wilson, and W logos.
Wilson A2000 SP14 SuperSkin 14" Slow Pitch Softball Glove: WBW10040414 $189.95 - $259.95 Price was: $329.95 Only at
Angled view of a dark brown and tan baseball catchers mitt with a deep pocket, black lacing, and ALL-STAR branding.
All Star S7 Elite 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM5000 $179.95 Price was: $299.95
Angled open view of a gray baseball glove with A2000 and Wilson on the palm, and a blue/yellow W logo on the back.
Wilson A2000 SuperSkin 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100396115 $219.95 Price was: $329.95
Open view of a tan baseball catchers mitt with black lacing, Rawlings logo, and PRO PREFERRED embossed on the palm.
Rawlings Pro Preferred 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: PROSCM43CBS $419.99 Out of Stock
Angled view of two gray and black softball gloves with blue and pink accents, one showing A2000 Wilson on the palm.
Wilson A2000 SuperSkin SP13 Spin Control 13" Slow Pitch Softball Glove: WBW10040213 $179.95 - $299.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of two tan baseball gloves with A2000 and Wilson branding on the palm, and a prominent W logo on the back.
Wilson A2000 DP15 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100108115 $289.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of two tan and black baseball mitts, one open showing the Rawlings Heart of the Hide embossed palm.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORDCT-10C $329.99
Angled view of two white Mizuno softball mitts with gray lacing, showing a deep pocket and X-laced web.
Mizuno MVP Prime 13" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: GXF50FPW2 $129.95
Angled view of a grey baseball glove with A2000 and Wilson on the palm, black lacing, and a textured Super SnakeSkin back.
Wilson A2000 Super SnakeSkin TA7 Tim Anderson 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW101019115 $209.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled front view of a brown first base mitt with embossed A2000 logo, two-tone lacing, and a single post web.
Wilson A2000 AC4 Amanda Chidester 12.5" Fastpitch First Base Mitt: WBW101017125 $139.95 - $179.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $154.95
Front angled view of a gray baseball glove with a black raised fist graphic, Wilson on the palm, and textured Super SnakeSkin back.
Wilson A2000 Super SnakeSkin TA7 Tim Anderson 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100433115 $189.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of two black baseball gloves with white lacing, one showing a textured A2000 palm, the other a yellow W logo.
Wilson A2000 1786 Spin Control 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW100985115 $229.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled front view of a tan and black baseball glove with A2K, 1786, and Wilson logos on the palm, and a gold W logo.
Wilson A2K 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW101373115 $319.95 Price was: $449.95
Angled front view of a tan baseball glove with blue lacing, A2000 and Wilson branding on the palm.
Wilson A2000 Bobby Witt Jr. 11.75" Baseball Glove: WBW1040681175 $329.95 Only at
Open view of a black and tan fastpitch softball glove with A2000 logo, W logo, and intricate lacing.
Wilson A2000 P12 12" Fastpitch Softball Glove: WBW10043912 $149.95 - $209.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of a dark brown baseball glove with gold Rawlings Pro Preferred logo, tan lacing, and Rawlings wrist script.
Rawlings Pro Preferred 11.75" Baseball Glove: RPROS315-2MO $349.95 Price was: $379.99
Angled view of two black baseball gloves, one showing the palm, the other the back, with tan lacing and Rawlings branding.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 11.75" Baseball Glove: PROR205-4DS $329.95
Angled view of a black and white baseball glove with a black palm, A2000 and Wilson text, and yellow W logo.
Wilson A2000 SuperSkin 1786 11.5" Baseball Glove: WBW101395115 $229.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $174.95
Front and back view of tan and black baseball gloves with red lacing, A2000 on the palm, and black Super Snakeskin back.
Wilson A2000 Super Snakeskin PF88 11.25" Baseball Glove: WBW1001071125 $309.95 Price was: $329.95

Our Expert Picks

We know there is a lot to choose from.
Get our experts’ favorite gloves.
Learn More

Angled front view of a tan and black baseball catchers mitt with an open pocket, All-Star logo, and Pro-Elite branding.
All Star Pro Elite 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: CM3000SBT $449.95 Used from $384.95 Some of the top catchers in baseball choose the All Star Pro Elite Series and I can see why. Great pocket that "pops" and the Japanese Tanned Steerhide really does break-in quick buts holds its shape and structure in all the right places. - Mac M.
Angled view of a tan leather softball glove showing Shoeless Joe logo and 1400 on palm, with crisscross lacing on back.
Shoeless Joe Professional 14" Slow Pitch Softball Glove: 1400BW $199.95 Price was: $239.95 A Shoeless Joe gives you the look, feel and even the smell of an old-time glove. This one is 14" and excellent for use anywhere on a slow pitch diamond! - Ben L. Only at
Front 3/4 view of an olive green fastpitch softball glove with white accents, tan lacing, and A2000 and Wilson branding on the palm.
Wilson A2000 Super SnakeSkin FP50 12.25" Summer Collection Fastpitch Softball Glove: WBW1033001225 $179.95 - $239.95 Price was: $329.95 Perfect outfield glove for fastpitch! Muted color so I am not blasting color over the field but still stand out! Used options for an amazing price on an A2000!
Front-side view of an orange baseball glove with mint green lacing, a purple octopus graphic, and a swirl pattern.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Heat Check 11.5" Baseball Glove: PROR204W-2OPU $299.95 Price was: $329.99 This has been my favorite colorway from Rawlings in a very, very long time! This glove is truly a piece of art with the color accents and style. Only at
Load More Products

Put Our Expertise to Work

We know gloves - and we’re here to help you find the perfect fit. Get the right one for your game with these resources:

Sizing Guide

Determine the right size glove for you or your player

Glove Coach

Get just-for-you glove recommendations

Resource Guide

Find helpful information written by our roster of Experts

1-866-321-4568

support@justgloves.com

Show Comparison
4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews